Getting out of a directory or lead-seller contract
You pay every month for leads you don't own, and too many of them are people looking for free advice. Here's how a family-law firm builds marketing it owns, and moves off rented leads without the phone going quiet.
I'm Joshua David Little. I've run my own consulting firm since 2004, I've helped attorneys prepare complex cases for trial, and I ran the first family-law ad on ChatGPT, before the platform allowed legal-services ads.
Opening
Directories and lead sellers make it easy to start. You pay, the leads arrive, and you don't have to build anything. For a new firm that can be a reasonable first step.
Over time the costs add up. Directory plans start at around $400 a month, and pay-per-lead services charge per name, often $50 to $100 a lead.¹ Many firms find that a lot of the people they send are looking for free advice, or never answer when the firm calls back. And every month you stop paying, the leads stop.
What you're actually renting
When you buy leads or a directory listing, you're renting someone else's audience. The profile, the reviews on their platform, the traffic, and the people who never called all belong to them. If the price goes up or the quality drops, you start from zero.
The same thing happens with some agencies: the website, the ad accounts, and the data sit in the agency's name. If you leave, they stay. Before any change, find out what you own.
What owning it looks like
A firm that owns its marketing has its own website with pages for the situations its clients are in, its own Google Business Profile and reviews, its own ad accounts, and its own list of people who asked for help. Each piece keeps working whether or not you're paying a third party that month.
The list is the most valuable piece. Someone who downloads your guide today and isn't ready to hire is still on your list in three months, hearing from you, when they are. A lead seller's lead is gone the moment you don't call fast enough.
Moving over without a gap
Nobody should cancel a lead source on Friday and hope the phone rings Monday. The move works in steps:
- Measure what you're getting now. For each source, what a signed client actually costs you.
- Build the owned pieces beside it. The pages, the guide, the follow-up, and your own ads, pointed at the situations your best clients are in.
- Shift the budget as your own system proves itself. Cut the weakest rented source first, and keep the strongest one until your own numbers beat it.
When every lead is followed to the signed client, the decision about each source comes from your numbers.
What it can look like
Brenda Clark Family Law's ads offer free guides for people facing a divorce, every lead goes into her own list and is followed to the signed engagement, and she signs new clients for about $200 each. Everything that brings those clients in belongs to her firm.
As your Fractional CMO, I can run this for you, direct the agencies you already have, or train your own staff to run it. Everything we build is yours, and the engagement runs month to month.
¹ Published vendor pricing, as read by Aquila: directory plans from about $399 to $455 a month; pay-per-lead family-law services about $50 to $100 a lead.
